Hunting Area 1 in Crook, Wyoming, has mixed reviews with an emphasis on private land access being crucial for a successful whitetail hunt. Experienced hunters advise focusing on the south and eastern parts of the unit, where whitetails are more abundant, albeit primarily on private land. The high draw odds suggest good availability, but diseases like EHD and blue tongue have impacted deer populations significantly. Hunters express a preference for seeking permission on private lands and utilizing leftover doe tags, as well as coordinating directly with others for shared insights and strategies.